The short answer
A logistics team should pick the multi-carrier shipment tracking and visibility platform that passes a two week pilot on its own shipments, not the one with the best demo. ShipmentVisibility, a shipment tracking tool for US shippers with mixed carriers, wrote this guide for ops leads, customer service managers and IT owners who are about to buy. The method has three parts: evaluation from your freight mix, selection by measured pilot, and a four week implementation plan.
One honest note before the method. ShipmentVisibility does not pull live events from carriers yet, so plans are not on sale and it cannot be part of your pilot today. The free number check on this page reads parcel, PRO, container and air waybill numbers and links to each carrier page, which helps when you prepare the pilot list.
Facts table
| Item | ShipmentVisibility today |
|---|---|
| Price | No prices listed, plans not on sale |
| Billing period | None, nothing is charged |
| Works today | Free number check, up to 5 numbers, shareable result link |
| Live carrier events | Not connected yet |
| Built, waiting for live data | Shipment list, CSV import and export, manual milestones, delay email, exception alert |
Evaluation starts from your freight, not the feature list
Vendor feature lists are long and mostly the same. The differences that matter show up only when you hold the list against your own freight. Pull the last 90 days of shipments and count them by mode and carrier. Most mid-sized shippers find that five carriers carry 80 percent or more of the volume. Those five carriers are your real requirement, and a platform that covers them with live events beats one that claims hundreds of carriers but misses one of yours.
| Your freight | Must have | Nice to have |
|---|---|---|
| Mostly parcel, some LTL | Parcel coverage for every carrier you use, PRO tracking for your LTL carriers | Branded tracking page and customer emails |
| Mostly LTL and truckload | PRO and load reference tracking, a silent shipment rule of 48 hours, appointment dates | Carrier on-time scorecards by lane |
| Ocean and air imports | Container, booking and air waybill tracking, free time dates, vessel change alerts | Predicted arrival window per lane |
| Mixed, with suppliers booking freight | Search by your PO, a way for suppliers to add numbers, one status model | API push into the ERP |
Then write down who will use the platform each day. A customer service desk needs search by order and PO. An ops lead needs late and silent rules per mode. Finance needs an export. If you are still unsure whether you need a tracking platform or a full TMS, the TMS for shippers vs tracking software scorecard settles that first. For the categories of tools and how they differ, see which shipment tracking visibility software shippers should buy.
Selection by pilot, with pass marks written first
Ask the two or three vendors on your shortlist for a pilot on your own numbers. Pick 40 open shipments that match your mix, from at least five carriers, and load the same list into every platform on the same day. Write the pass marks down before you start, so nobody moves them after a good demo.
| Metric | Formula | Suggested pass mark |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Shipments with at least one event from the tool, divided by shipments loaded | 90 percent or more |
| Event lag | Median minutes between the carrier's scan time and the event in the tool | Under 60 minutes |
| ETA error | Average absolute hours between the predicted and the actual delivery | Under 12 hours for LTL and truckload |
| Alert precision | Alerts that were real problems, divided by all alerts sent | 70 percent or more |
Check each platform against the carrier's own tracking page every morning. Container numbers are easy to verify because the owner code and check digit follow ISO 6346, maintained through the BIC code registry. Air waybills carry a three digit airline prefix and a mod 7 check digit, and IATA's e-AWB program explains how the air waybill record moves between parties. Wrong numbers in the pilot list make every platform look bad, so run the list through the free check above first.
Worked example, a 40 shipment pilot
A building products distributor runs a two week pilot with three platforms. Its 40 shipments are 15 LTL PROs, 12 parcels, 8 truckloads and 5 containers. The figures below are an illustration of how to read pilot results, not measurements of real products.
| Result | Platform A | Platform B | Platform C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shipments loaded | 40 | 40 | 40 |
| Shipments with events | 38 (95 percent) | 31 (78 percent) | 36 (90 percent) |
| Median event lag | 25 min | 10 min | 95 min |
| ETA error, LTL and truckload | 9 h | 14 h | 11 h |
| Alerts sent, real problems | 12 sent, 9 real | 20 sent, 8 real | 9 sent, 7 real |
| Passes every mark | Yes | No | No (lag) |
Platform B has the fastest events but misses 9 of 40 shipments, mostly truckloads booked through a broker. Its 20 alerts include 12 false ones, which a customer service desk will learn to ignore within a week. Platform C covers well but its events arrive more than an hour and a half after the scan, so the desk would still be checking carrier sites before calling customers. Platform A passes every mark and becomes the choice, even if its quote is higher, because the cost of a missed truckload is a lost order, not a few dollars.
Keep the pilot data. The same delivered dates are the start of a carrier review, which our article on how shippers measure carrier on-time delivery rates explains step by step.
Implementation for teams, a four week plan
Most tracking rollouts fail on data and habits, not software. The promised delivery date is missing, the PO is in an email, and customer service keeps the old spreadsheet open just in case. A four week plan with a named owner per role keeps the project short.
| Week | Ops lead | Customer service | IT or ERP owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Clean data | Agrees the status list and late rules | Lists the 10 questions customers ask most | Exports open shipments with carrier number, PO and promised date |
| 2. Connect | Loads all open shipments, checks carrier names | Tests search by order and PO | Sets up the CSV routine or API push |
| 3. Tune rules | Sets silent limits per mode, reviews every alert | Says which alerts they actually acted on | Routes alerts to email or chat channels |
| 4. Go live | Retires the shared spreadsheet | Answers calls from the platform only | Schedules the weekly export for finance |
If your ERP or TMS will send shipments in, agree the field list in week one. The shipment tracking API page lists the fields a push integration needs. Retiring the spreadsheet in week four is the step teams skip, and it is the one that makes the platform the single answer to where is my order.
Questions to ask every vendor
- Which of my five busiest carriers are covered by a direct feed, and which by a third party data provider?
- What is your median event lag for those carriers, and can I see it in the pilot?
- How do I search by my PO or order number, not only the carrier number?
- Which alert rules can I set per mode, and who can receive them?
- How are prices counted: per shipment, per active shipment, per seat or per carrier?
- What happens to my data and exports if I cancel?
For a ranked view of tool types once the pilot is done, read best freight tracking software. The product side of multi-carrier tracking, with the formats each mode uses, is on the multi carrier tracking software page.
Who it is for and who it is not for
This method is for logistics teams at shippers using three or more carriers across modes, with between roughly 100 and a few thousand shipments a month, who are buying their first tracking platform or replacing one that did not work. It is not for fleets tracking their own trucks by GPS, for single carrier shippers who are well served by the carrier's own portal, or for enterprises whose rollout is run by a systems integrator.
What ShipmentVisibility does today
ShipmentVisibility does not pull live events from carriers yet, so plans are not on sale. Join the list and we will email you when live tracking opens. The free check reads the format of a parcel, LTL PRO, container or air waybill number, validates the check digit where the format has one, names the carrier where the number identifies it and links to the carrier's own tracking page. The shipment list, CSV import and export, manual milestones and delay email are built and waiting for live carrier data.
FAQ
How do you evaluate a multi-carrier shipment tracking and visibility platform?
Start from your own freight mix, not the vendor's feature list. Write down your top carriers and modes, then run a two week pilot on 40 of your own shipments and measure coverage, event lag and ETA error against the carriers' own pages. Choose on those numbers.
How long does it take to implement a multi-carrier tracking platform?
For a mid-sized shipper that loads shipments by CSV or API, plan about four weeks: one to clean references and promised dates, one to connect data, one to tune alert rules and one to train customer service. Enterprise rollouts with many carrier integrations take longer.
What should a pilot of a tracking platform measure?
Measure three numbers. Coverage is the share of shipments with at least one event from the tool. Event lag is the median delay between the carrier scan and the tool. ETA error is the average gap between predicted and actual delivery. Write the pass marks down before the pilot starts.
Can I buy ShipmentVisibility today?
ShipmentVisibility does not pull live events from carriers yet, so plans are not on sale. Join the list and we will email you when live tracking opens. The free number check works today.