A worked scorecard for three candidate tools
Give each requirement a weight that adds up to 100, score each tool from 1 to 5 after a test on your own numbers, and multiply. The tools and scores below are an illustration of the method, not ratings of real products.
Tool A wins on coverage and loses on price and on search by order number. Tools B and C tie, but for different reasons: B is fast, C is cheap and easy for customer service. A tie is useful information. It tells you to ask the vendors of B and C for one more week of testing on the carrier where each one scored lowest, instead of choosing on a demo.
Weights should follow your freight. A wholesaler with 70 percent LTL puts more weight on PRO coverage and silent rules. An importer weights ocean coverage and free time dates. The full method, with a pilot plan and a rollout plan for the team, is in our article on how logistics teams evaluate a multi-carrier tracking and visibility platform.