Skip to content
ShipmentVisibility

Carrier Tracking Software for Shippers Compared

Carrier tracking software puts every carrier in one list and flags the late shipments. Below: the four kinds of tool, a worked cost of tracking by hand and a comparison table.

Test it with your own numbers

Mode and carrier are detected instantly, and live events show after you create your account.

The short answer

Carrier tracking software for a shipper is a single list that follows shipments across every carrier you use, flags the late ones and tells you before a customer does. If you use one or two carriers, their own portals are enough. From three carriers up, or once LTL, parcel and ocean mix, a tracking tool pays for itself in saved hours. For most small and mid-sized shippers, a flat-priced tool such as multi-carrier tracking beats a quote-based enterprise platform.

This page compares the four kinds of tool buyers actually choose between and puts a number on the manual alternative. For a scored shortlist of named vendors, see best freight tracking software compared.

Four kinds of carrier tracking tools

Carrier portals. Free, accurate for that carrier, and one login each. Fine for two carriers. They never show a combined late list.

Parcel aggregators. Built for ecommerce parcel tracking and branded notifications. Strong on UPS, FedEx and USPS, usually thin on LTL PRO numbers and ocean. Read AfterShip alternatives if freight is part of your mix.

TMS or ERP modules. Good when every load is booked inside the system. Blind to freight booked outside it and often to ocean containers.

Freight visibility platforms. Enterprise network tools with carrier integrations and quote-based pricing. Powerful, and sized for shippers with thousands of loads. See project44 alternatives and FourKites alternatives.

A fifth option sits between the last two: a flat-priced, multi-mode tool you can buy by card. That is the lane ShipmentVisibility is built for, with LTL, parcel, truckload, ocean and air in one list from $49 a month.

What manual carrier tracking costs

The honest alternative to software is a person with open browser tabs. Here is a worked example with assumed figures, so you can swap in your own.

Manual tracking time and cost example
InputAssumed valueResult
Shipments per week150 across five carriers
Status checks per shipment2 on average, 2 minutes each600 minutes a week
Where-is-it calls and emails10 a week, 12 minutes each120 minutes a week
Total tracking time12 hours a week, about 52 hours a month
Loaded cost of that time$30 an hour$1,560 a month
Software cost, Growth plan$149 a month for 750 shipmentsAbout a tenth of the manual cost

Software does not remove all of that time. If it cuts the routine in half and makes the exception list the only thing you check, you still save most of the $1,560, before counting late shipments caught a day earlier. The break-even is low. At $30 an hour, the $149 plan pays for itself in five hours of saved work a month.

Your numbers will differ, and a small shipper with 30 shipments a week may be fine on carrier portals. The test is simple: if you check more than three carrier sites before lunch, you are the buyer.

Carrier tracking software compared

Types of carrier tracking software compared
TypeModesPricing modelBest for
Carrier portalsOne carrier eachFreeShippers with one or two carriers
Parcel aggregatorsParcel firstMonthly by volume, often per shipment tiers (confirm on vendor page)Ecommerce brands shipping mostly parcel
TMS or ERP modulesLoads booked in the systemBundled with the systemShippers already running a TMS
Freight visibility platformsAll modes, enterpriseQuote based, annual (confirm with vendor)Large shippers with thousands of loads
ShipmentVisibilityLTL, FTL, parcel, ocean, air$49, $149, $499 and $1,499 a month, no contractSmall and mid-sized mixed-mode shippers

Cells that say confirm are prices we could not verify publicly and we do not guess them. Check the vendor page on the day you buy.

Teams that automate their finance side next to logistics sometimes route carrier invoices into a payment workflow too, for example with Pdfqbo for converting PDF bank statements into QuickBooks files. That is a separate job from tracking, but it is the same back office.

How to choose in a week

Day one, list your carriers and mark the two you use most. Day two, take 20 live numbers, including your worst carrier, and load them into your shortlisted tools. Day three to six, note which tool showed the first exception and which got every status right. Day seven, count the minutes you spent on carrier sites. Pick the tool that needed the fewest.

Check three things before you pay: that the carrier is detected without manual setup, that alerts reach the person who acts on them, and that the price on the page is the price on the invoice. Our freight visibility software pricing breakdown explains how quote-based and flat pricing differ. For LTL detail, read LTL tracking software. To judge carrier quality itself, see the Bureau of Transportation Statistics at bts.gov.

If you mainly care about outbound customer orders, delivery tracking software for shippers shows how the one list works day to day.

FAQ

What is carrier tracking software?

Carrier tracking software pulls shipment status from many carriers into one list, so a shipper does not open each carrier site separately. Good tools detect the carrier from the number, flag late and stalled shipments and alert you before the customer asks.

How much does carrier tracking software cost?

Prices run from about $49 a month for small shippers to quote-only annual contracts for enterprise networks. ShipmentVisibility publishes $49, $149, $499 and $1,499 a month with no contract. Quote-based vendors usually require a sales call to see any price.

Do I need carrier tracking software if my TMS tracks shipments?

Only if your freight is all booked inside the TMS and all carriers send it status. Shipments booked outside it, parcel, ocean containers and customer-arranged freight usually are not covered. A tracking tool on top fills those gaps without replacing the TMS.

Can carrier tracking software track LTL and parcel together?

Yes, if it supports both PRO numbers and parcel tracking numbers. Many parcel-first tools handle UPS and FedEx well and miss regional LTL carriers. Test your worst carrier with a live number before you pay.

Replace the carrier tabs with one list

Choose a plan, paste this week's numbers and start with the exceptions. Plans start at $49 a month with no contract.

See pricing